Tuesday 26 August 2008

BPO’s FIASCO!

It has been widely debated whether the growth of Business Processing Outsourcing (BPO) industry has been good for our country and more importantly for our culture. The subject has not been adequately addressed in a manner that will provide an insight to our youngsters, especially those who are most often lured by the seemingly lucrative packages that the industry puts out.

Considering the economic prosperity and massive employment that the BPO has brought, it surely makes BPOs one of the most sought after industries. But let us see what happens once an individual lands up working in a BPO? First he is stripped of his identity. Krishna becomes Chris, Janardhanan becomes John and Saraswathi becomes Sara and so on. They are trained in an accent that belongs neither here nor there. In short the individual’s identity is robbed and replaced by a convenient one to satisfy the economics of the trade.

Secondly, We also need to ask if our teenagers are being robbed of their youth to work like mechanized robots in a demanding industry. The age group of 18 to 25 is the crucial time in a person's life in which he/she acquires skills that will sustains him/her on the long run. The lure of easy money can deprive them of acquiring skills that are more sustaining and meaningful in life.

Thirdly, the industry has encouraged the growth of synthetic westernization which has adversely affected our cultural and traditional outlook. Our oriental values lay great stress on the principles and values of Karma. Karma emphasizes on a value system that puts duty above the considerations of material benefit. It underlines the principle of altruism in its purest form. The hefty pay packages offered by the industry to lure youngsters, kills this spirit and is the classic example of synthetic material values creeping into our culture.

It is often being argued that BPOs provide opportunities for those who do not have anything else to sustain themselves in life. With some basic English speaking skills a financially strained person can earn up to Rs, 20,000. Undoubtedly, BPOs have come as a savior for thousands of unemployed youngsters and has also helped considerably in raising their standard of living. What concerns me the most is that this opportunity is misguiding our youth. In many ways it has killed initiative and creativity by languishing in a vacuum like environment called call centres.

Last but not the least, the amount of freedom that a night working schedule bestows, is more often than not misused. Practices like drinking, one night stands, and drugs have become a part and parcel of their life style. And at this tender age it becomes almost impossible for them to discern the difference between right and wrong.

The need of the hour is to provide proper guidance to youngsters by creating awareness about a larger more meaningful world with great opportunities for creative skills, improvisation and higher education. They must be made to understand that there are various other creative areas to develop one's personality and call centres are only a short cut to mediocre wealth. This initiative should be made by parents and teachers alike.

While BPO’s may offer some hope in a country with great unemployment, one must remember there is a life and scope beyond this instant moneymaking profession.

WRITTEN BY :PRIYANKA CHAUHAN


7 comments:

Anonymous said...

Hey Priyanka Well written, I think we bot are making similar.

Do have a look, http://thetoptenme.wordpress.com/2008/09/03/10-thoughts-scare-this-cheap-indian-labor/

Anonymous said...

Hey Priyanka Well written, I think we both are making similar points.

Do have a look, http://thetoptenme.wordpress.com/2008/09/03/10-thoughts-scare-this-cheap-indian-labor/

wandering soul said...

Yeah Chirax, I do agree our points are quite similar but approach is different. And thanx for such an amazing link.

Priyanka Chauhan

Indian Home Maker said...

Priyanka I understand your concerns but
1.Seeing how much better it is for the youth to be employed and occupied than to be loitering, and getting into trouble, or creating trouble;falling (easy) prey to upcoming politicians etc, I am glad they are busy. We Indians are an ambitious lot, we all want to go for IIT and IIM, since all students are not able to get into these and other such institutes, BPOs are a blessing for the 'average' student. Frustration turns to hope, they start earlier even if they cannot make as much as their class toppers do, at least they are self reliant.

2.About loss of identity - It is just a job. Do our actors loose their identity? What will happen to their identity if they were jobless? Financial independence does not create any trouble unless the tendency to drink/drugs/smoke etc was already there. Don't the poor drink? In fact their frustrations make them drink more.

3.Our culture TALKS about karma and altruism, but everywhere we are running after 'maya moh' (which is why this medical and engineering, and management obsession). Hefty pay package makes them value their jobs (and understand their 'duty' is to work hard!).

What is Synthetic Westernization?
Trained accents? Love for money?

I have seen average students, who would have taken mediocre jobs and suffered miserable complexes, finding confidence with a comfortable pay packet in a BPO job. The choice is not really between creativity or a BPO job, it is more often a choice between joblessness and a BPO job. I also know of a middle aged widow, who found the tough life (it is a difficult routine)of BPO a blessing, it gave her the wonderful power only money can give - to raise her school going child comfortably - she could afford tuition for her, which she could not earlier.

I totally agree with your point about /creating awareness about a larger and more meaningful world with greater opportunities for creative skills, improvisations and higher education/.

wandering soul said...

Hi Homemaker,

It's great to know that you feel so strongly about the subject that you actually thought of leaving a comment. Welcome to my blog.

Now, as for your objections, Let me try and give clarifications on that.

1) "we all want to go for IIT and IIM, since all students are not able to get into these and other such institutes, BPOs are a blessing for the 'average' student."----HOMEMAKER

Look, IIT'S AND IIM'S aren't an end to the world. There is a lot for a person to invest and explore if he/she is not able to make it to the top notch institutes. Moreover,a BPO job is not a blessing for an "average student" as you pointed out rather it spells disaster in the guise of blessing. Because that average person could have earned for himself a lot more stable and skill oriented job than BPOS had ther been some guidance, awareness and hard work . Whereas he lands up wasting his raw talent in an industry which doesn't support an individual to have a long term vision about his future.Youngsters working in a BPO nurture short term goals accompanied by the mantra to work hard and party harder. This is not the way youngsters ought to be thinking, especially at such a tender age.

2)As for actors are concerned, look there is no point of comparison between the two professions( Acting and BPOS). Actors playing different characters, getting into the soul of an identity which is not theirs, is a challenging task which is highly creative. Whereas a BPO job confers an identity which is robotic in nature making a person sounds like an IVR machine repeating same information over and over.



However I do agree, that for those who haven't been able to carve out a niche for themselves in other fields can fit in here easily. They can earn well too.

But my view is that money isn't evrything in life there is this thing called 'job satifaction' which this industry completely lacks.



Priyanka

Anonymous said...

Well written Priyanka.

wandering soul said...

Thanx prerna ..appreciation from talented bloggers like you always encourages ....

My son's birthday Gems Choco Cake (eggless)

Today is my son's fourth birthday. I don't know where the time has flown. It seems he was born just yesterday. Well, I bet all the ...